Dr Kevin Smith

Senior Lecturer

School School of Science, Engineering and Technology

Department Division of Science

Contact info

+44 (0)1382 30 8664

Biography

I teach and research in the related areas of bioethics and genetics.

My research interests are focused on the ethical issues arising in respect of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) and genetics. I am committed to the principles of science-based medicine and apply bioethical analysis to pseudoscientific CAM modalities such as homeopathy.

I have led the University's successful Biomedical Science (BMS) degree programme since 2004. It is the highest rated BMS programme in Scotland as rated by students in the National Student Survey, and was recently ranked by the Guardian League Table as within the top three programmes in Scotland in the domain of bioscience.. 

My research has received national and international attention beyond academia. I have been asked on various occasions to provide my views as an expert on contemporary bioethical issues by local, national and international media.

Outside of University, windsurfing and cycling keep me busy.

General

  • Specialist Teaching Areas: Bioethics and Genetics.
  • Delivery of broad range of modules covering genetics, bioethics and physiology, spanning undergraduate level (Years 1-4 inclusive) to postgraduate level.
  • Design and delivery of Honours projects (several per year).
  • CPD course design and delivery.

Links between teaching and research

My work is directly relevant to biomedical science in general, and therefore directly relevant to the BMS programme. It is my responsibility to teach bioethics on the BMS programme – NB bioethics is an essential (and indeed growing) element of biomedical science – and my research strongly informs my teaching in this domain.  Every year I provide a number of innovative projects, which are keenly sought after by BMS students.

My research is in bioethics and theoretical genetics. My ethical perspective is utilitarian. I am particularly interested in ethical issues arising in respect of [a] so-called 'Complementary and Alternative Medicine' (CAM) and [b] genetics. In terms of CAM, I apply bioethical analysis to CAM ethics in general and particularly to the pseudoscientific modality of homeopathy. My conclusions from such analyses, thus far, have been highly negative: there are serious ethical concerns surrounding CAM - and I believe that these issues need to be articulated in order to prevent patient harm and maximise support for scientific medicine. Indeed, I argue that there exists an ethical duty on bioethicists, physicians, scientists and educators to work to inform the public about the ethical problems associated with CAM. In terms of ethical issues arising in the domain of genetics (known as 'genethics'), I am particularly interested in genetic modification (GM), especially where this affects (directly or indirectly) humans, with my work encompassing transgenic bioreactors, xenotransplanatation, GM food, gene therapy and genetic enhancement. I believe that we require a new 'green revolution' if the world's growing population is to be sustained, and that this revolution, if realised, will be based upon GM technology. In this respect I suggest that attempts to prevent the development and use of GM food technology are ethically reprehensible. I further suggest that science and society has an ethical imperative to work towards effective and safe forms of human genetic modification and enhancement technologies: such technologies hold the potential for major improvements in human health and quality of life in the future. Another area of genethics I am interested in is the occurrence of de novo mutations in the human germline: I suggest that this fact of nature throws up some important ethical questions - for example, in respect of procreative decisions including the ethics of delayed fatherhood. In respect of bioethics more broadly, I regret the obscurantist and anti-analytical trend that is becoming increasingly apparent in at least some strands of recent (bio)ethical discourse. I suggest that postmodernism is partly to blame for this, as is the rise of the career ethicist and the ethics industry in general. However, bioethics matters: ethically informed medical policy and practice is crucially important to people and to society. Bioethicists are, I suggest, under an obligation to make their voices heard. For example, many bioethicists (including myself) consider it to be a travesty that terminally ill patients in the UK are denied the option of physician assisted suicide; but this is not simply an academic issue: committed bioethicists ought not to rest in the pursuit of practical progress towards allieviating suffering, by repeatedly arguing for a change in legislation to give patients the option of ending their lives in dignity and freedom from suffering.

  • Ernst, E. & Smith, K. More Harm than Good? The Moral Maze of Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2018. (Book.) Springer. ISBN: 978-3319699400.
  • Smith, K. Applied Reproductive System: Scientific Aspects. 2018. (Book chapter; p83-98.) In: Kwansa, TD & Stewart-Moore, J. (eds) Evidence-Based Sexual And Reproductive Health Care. Jones and Bartlett. ISBN: 978-1284114942.
  • Smith, K., Colquhoun, D., Ernst, E. & Sampson, W. Complementary & Alternative Medicine' (CAM): Ethical And Policy Issues. Bioethics, 2016; 30(2): SI 60-62.
  • Smith, K. Religion, Secular Medicine and Utilitarianism: a Response to Biggar. Journal of Medical Ethics, 2015; 41(11): 867-869.
  • Smith, K. Paternal Age Bioethics. Journal of Medical Ethics, 2015; 41(9): 775-779.
  • Smith, K. Synthetic Biology: A Utilitarian Perspective. Bioethics, 2013; 27(8): SI 453-463.
  • Smith, K., Chan, S. & Harris, J. Reply: Human Germline Genetic Modification: Scientific and Bioethical Perspectives. Archives of Medical Research, 2013; 44(4): 323-323.
  • De Vasconcelos, Alana; Campos, Vinicius Farias; Nedel, Fernanda; et al. Cytotoxic and apoptotic effects of chalcone derivatives of 2-acetyl thiophene on human colon adenocarcinoma cells. Cell Biochemistry and Function, 2013; 31(4): Volume: 289-297.
  • Smith, K., Chan, S. & Harris, J. Human Germline Genetic Modification: Scientific and Bioethical Perspectives. Archives of Medical Research, 2012; 43(7): 491-513.
  • Smith, K (ed). Sperm-Mediated Gene Transfer: Concepts and Controversies. (Edited eBook.) 2012. Bentham Science Publishers. eISBN: 978-1-60805-237-0.
  • Smith, K. Homeopathy is Unscientific and Unethical. Bioethics, 2012; 26(9): 508-512.
  • Smith, K. Why homeopathy is unethical. Focus on Alternative and Complementary Therapies, 2011; 16(3): 193-251.
  • Oliveira, R.S., Collares, T.F., Smith, K., et al. The use of genes for performance enhancement: doping or therapy? Brazilian Journal of Medical and Biological Research, 2011; 44(12): 1194-1201.
  • Smith, K. Factors influencing the inclusion of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in undergraduate medical education. BMJ Open, 2011; 1(1): Art. No. e000074.
  • Smith, K. Against Homeopathy – A Utilitarian Perspective. Bioethics, 2011; 26(8): 398-409.
  • Smith, K. Anomalous therapies and public health: A utilitarian bioethical response. Public Health Nursing, 2008; 25(3): 269-277.
  • Sampson, W. & Smith, K. Word Use and Semantics in “Alternative Medicine”; a Survey of Editors of Medical & Related Journals. Medscape General Medicine, 2008; 10(5): 125.
  • Smith, K. Animal Genetic modification - A Utilitarian Response. (Chapter in edited book ‘The Animal Ethics Reader’, Eds Armstrong & Botzler, 2008, Routledge, London. ISBN-13: 978-0415775397.)
  • Smith K. & Spadafora, C. Sperm-mediated Gene Transfer: Applications and Implications. BioEssays, 2005; 27(5): 551-562.
  • Smith, K. Biomedical Ethics: A Utilitarian Perspective. International Journal of Ethics, 2005 5(3-4):179-196.
  • Smith, K. Human Germline Genetic Modification - a Utilitarian Bioethical Perspective. (Chapter in edited book ‘Trends in Gene Therapy Research’, 2005, Nova Publishers, New York. ISBN 1-59454-306-2.)
  • Smith K. Gene Therapy: The Potential Applicability of Gene Transfer technology to the Human Germline. International Journal of Medical Science, 2004; 1(2): 76-91.
  • Smith, K. The Ethics of Anomalous, Unconventional Therapies: A Utilitarian Response. The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine, 2003;7(1):26-28.
  • Smith, K. Gene Therapy: Theoretical and Bioethical Concepts. Archives of Medical Research, 2003; 34(4): 247-268.
  • Smith, K. Problems of Affluence in Morality. Philosophy Now, 2002; (38):28-31.
  • Smith, K. Animal Genetic modification - A Utilitarian Response. Bioethics, 2002; 16(1): 55-71.
  • Smith K. Gene Transfer in Higher Animals: Theoretical Considerations and Key Concepts. Journal of Biotechnology, 2002; 99(1):1-22.
  • Smith K. The Role of Sperm-Mediated Gene Transfer in Genome Mutation and Evolution. Medical Hypotheses, 2002; 59(4): 433-437.
  • Smith K. Theoretical Mechanisms in Targeted and Random Integration of Transgene DNA. Reproduction Nutrition Development, 2001; 41(6) :465-485.
  • Smith K. Sperm Cell Mediated Transgenesis: A Review. Animal Biotechnology, 1999; 10(1-2): 1-13.

More Information

Esteem

Citations & impact

Excluding publications since 2015, which are too new to have generated significant citations, my journal papers have generated an average of 21 citations each, with the top paper generating 154 citations. This is a high citation rate, particularly considering that bioethics articles are cited at a much lower rate than empirical scientific or medical papers. Moreover, around 75% of my research output is in the form of single-author papers. (Most of the remainder of my articles have 2-4 authors; only 2 articles have more than 4 authors.) This demonstrates that the vast majority of my citations/impact success is attributable entirely to my own work.

Several of the journals I publish in are particularly highly ranked in their field. The most prominent are the Journal of Medical Ethics (JME) and the Bioethics journal. I have published a total of 7 articles in these two journals. The JMEs is the world’s top-ranked journal in bioethics for 2015 according to Google Scholar Metrics, with an impact factor of 1.511 and an h5-index of 28; and the Bioethics journal is ranked 4th, with an impact factor of 1.483 and an h5-index of 22. It should of course be noted that such metrics do not give the whole measure of research quality, and I personally am opposed to any simplist uses of impact or related measures to assess output, e.g. as has been proposed for the next REF.

Wider Impact

My research has received national and international attention beyond academia, leading to media coverage including TV, radio and print media interviews. Due to my research-related esteem, I have often been asked to provide views on topical matters of medical science and ethics, including media interviews, debates and solicited commentaries.

To take the most recent example, in 2015 my JME paper ‘Paternal Age Bioethics’ drew a great deal of attention from the media. I was interviewed several times for various broadcast and print media, leading to news and features coverage on various forums including:

• TV, including BBC1 & ITV
• Radio, including BBC Radio 1, 2, & 4, Radio Scotland, and local stations
• BBC World Service
• Newspapers, including the Daily Mail, Guardian and Telegraph
• Magazines, including Cosmopolitan, and FHM.

In terms of academic responses, my paper also generated a good deal of commentary online, including expert opinions and web articles. For example, my paper ‘Against Homeopathy – A Utilitarian Perspective’ (Bioethics journal, 2011) generated a great deal of media and academic interest. In addition to broadcast and media coverage, including interviews, this publication had notable impact in academic and medical circles. My paper was ranked in the top 40 worldwide of all medical ethics articles published that year, at position 32.  It has been mentioned in a number of professional periodicals for practitioners in the fields of medicine, dentistry and veterinary medicine, on account of the paper’s arguments against the use of homeopathy as a therapeutic modality.

On a number of occasions I have been asked to provide my views as an expert on contemporary bioethical issues by local, national and international media.

Other indicators of esteem

I was returned to the most recent Research Assessment Exercise (REF 2014), as well as to its predecessor (RAE 2008). I expect to be returned in the next REF.

Member of the editorial board of the Focus on Alternative and Complementary Therapies (FACT) journal.

Chief guest editor for a 2016 special edition of the Bioethics journal.

Ad hoc peer-review for a number of high ranking journals (including JME, Bioethics, BioEssays, Medical Hypotheses, Theriogenology, Molecular Reproduction & Development, and Stem Cell Reviews).

Invited reviewer for academic books for both Wiley and the Oxford University Press.

Collaborators

I collaborate with high profile international researchers. Published output has resulted from my collaborations with the following highly prominent individuals:

Professor David Colquhoun, FRS
Professor of Pharmacology
University College London (UCL)
http://www.dcscience.net/

Professor Edzard Ernst, MD, PhD, FMedSci, FSB, FRCP, FRCPEd
Professor of Complementary Medicine
University of Exeter
http://edzardernst.com/about/

Professor John Harris, FMedSci., FRSA., B.A., D.Phil., Hon. D.Litt.
Lord David Alliance Professor of Bioethics & Director of iSEI
Manchester University
http://www.manchester.ac.uk/research/john.harris/

Dr Wallace Sampson, MD (deceased 2015)
Clinical Professor of Medicine
Stanford University
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wallace_Sampson

Dr Corrado Spadafora, PhD
National Institute of Health
Rome, Italy
http://www.thethirdwayofevolution.com/people/view/corrado-spadafora

Outreach

I have been an invited speaker at popular science events; particularly ‘Skeptics in the Pub’ talks/debates (Aberdeen, Dundee, Edinburgh and Glasgow).

Meet the rest of the team

Dr Douglas Lester

Dr Douglas Lester

Division of Science | Lecturer

View profile

Dr Alexey Goltsov

Dr Alexey Goltsov

Division of Science | Lecturer

View profile